What has sprung from the mind and what has not? That is the question

People ain’t stupid. They have strong intuitions about how they might be connected to other humans. This is why a bidder paid USD$3.9 million for Pink Floyd guitarist David Gilmour’s black 1969 Fender Stratocaster, which is largely indistinguishable (apart from a few mods, mostly electronic) from a Stratocaster you could buy for around $2,000 from a local guitar shop. The extreme premium paid is a measure of the guitar’s connection to Gilmour.

Cognitive psychologist and psycholinguist Steven Pinker reckons standards of humanness are much higher for intellectual products, like stories and editorials – and advertising. “The awareness that there’s a real human you can connect it to changes its status and its acceptability,” he said.

This and more in Vernacular NICELY SAID issue 40.

  • Standing out – Fewer people want to
  • The real world – getting back in touch
  • Celebrated openings – Hard to put this book down
  • Verbed – First Google, now ChatGPT
  • Fashion – Tinfoil hat
  • Man vs Machine – Robots excel at table tennis

Read | Subscribe